Baby Talkers

Keep up to date with whats going on at BabyTalkers.
Subscribe to our Feed
.


Sometimes It Just Doesn’t Work Out

I’ve been having issues from the get-go with breast feeding my new baby. A week and a half ago, I wrote about him being too lazy to eat - basically couldn’t latch on correctly and continuously falling asleep. We tried and tried and tried. I took him for his 2 week check up on Monday (which was really 16 days past birth) and sadly he had lost weight since we were last there, 9 days before, to check on his weight and billirubin number. My poor baby is painfully thin and my doctor was extremely concerned.

Some of the reasons I chose this particular pediatrician is because he is supportive of my decision to delay or deny vaccinations and he is very pro-breastfeeding, in addition to being really great with my older son. I’m mentioning this so you all understand the fact that he actually listens to his patients and seems to truly care about what is best for them. That being said, at each appointment (I went every day for like 5 days) he kept encouraging me to continue breast feeding, but when we got to this last appointment and Jett had actually lost weight…not just hadn’t gained or gained slowly, but actually LOST weight, he told me from a medical standpoint that I should not continue. I was devastated.

As I sat there crying in my pediatrician’s exam room, he brought me tissues, sympathized with me, and gently explained that this just isn’t healthy for Jett. My child needs to gain weight and I’m not providing him with enough milk and/or calories to do so. I cried for two days. I don’t understand how I was able to feed and fatten up my oldest son for over a year, but I can’t do the same for my youngest one.

No wonder Jett was ALWAYS wanting to eat. I’m not exaggerating. I could sit there for an hour and a half trying to feed him and he would not be satisfied. Sometimes I would then even give him 2 ounces of formula and he still seemed frustrated and wanting to eat more. I’d put him down, thinking he was full and happy, and he’d fuss 5 minutes later. I feel terrible now, knowing he was literally starving.

Jumping to the positives, because I’m done being upset about it, he is a different baby now that he’s eating. He is soooooo good and happy. He is much more alert and rarely cries. I just have to keep telling myself that myself, my husband, most of my friends and actually most of my friends’ babies, were not breast fed and we are ALL fine. We are all happy, intelligent, healthy, functioning people and my baby will be the same. Formula is not poison. Bottle feeding is not evil. In fact, it’s pretty damn convenient and I’m actually enjoying it now that I’m getting used to it.

  • Anyone can feed my baby, therefore anyone can watch my baby, at any time.
  • DH gets to share night time feedings with me (and there are only 2 so it works out great!!)
  • He’s on more of a schedule so I can expect exactly when he will want to eat and it’s not as often.
  • I am not nearly as tired!!!
  • I can tell how much he’s eating.
  • I don’t feel tied down at all. Honestly all I did, all day long, was breast feed.
  • I can now spend more time with my older son. :)
  • I don’t have to worry so much about what I eat and drink.

Ok, I realize (almost) all of those reasons are completely and utterly selfish, but it is what it is (my new fave saying). I already know all of the benefits of breast feeding and the cons of bottle feeding and I know what I’m going to be missing, but I can’t change it.

I quit BFing cold turkey and the crazy thing is that my breasts did not even get that engorged. That is how low my milk supply was. I mean, they really really hurt, but they didn’t get that full and hard. What I’ve used to help with the pain/swelling:

  • Extra strength tylenol every 4 hours
  • Green cabbage leaves
  • Ace bandage for binding (had to take it off after a few hours, it was too tight and painful
  • Sports bras
  • Breast pads

I’m hoping tomorrow I wake up with less or no pain. The physical reminder of what I’m giving up really bothers me. I’m starting to feel better all around though, so once this is past me, I am going to feel like a new person. I’m getting more sleep, post partum bleeding has really dwindled, and my spirits will be up once I know my baby has gained some weight!!



Comments:

  1. Oh, C . I'm sorry bfing didn't work out with Jett, but as you said -- you're doing absolutely nothing wrong by not bfing. You're doing everything right. You're listening to little man's needs, and he's obviously doing great . I love all your pros, and I'm honestly not sure if I could do it a 2nd time around (if #2 is anything like G, I know I won't be able to). Your views of it definitely ease my worries that I won't. Only 4 kids out of my entire family bf'd, and G's the only one that was EBF. They're all perfectly happy, healthy, wonderful kids. Now you've got one more memory that will always be just for Jax, and you get to experience something totally new (always a good thing!).
  2. Aw, C, I'm sorry it didn't work out for you. I felt a bit that way when I quit bf'ing B so early too. You are an awesome mom and I'm glad Jett is starting to wake up and that you are getting to spend more time with J now.
  3. Aww poor C!! I am sorry that it didn't work out for you!! Keep your chin up it will be ok.
  4. Oh, C, I'm so sorry! I know the feelings of frustration & guilt when things don't work out the way we want with our kids. But you are so right, this is what formula is FOR, and it's not evil AT ALL. You are a great mom, and you are doing what's best for YOUR son. Breast ISN'T always best, and nobody should give you a hard time about it.

    I'm glad that the transition is going well and that you're not in too much pain! I'm also thrilled (as I'm sure you are) that Jett is doing so well & is happy with a full little tummy.

    Hugs to you all!
  5. Oh honey, you are so right. Bottle feeding is NOT the devil. It's funny how it is construed that way now, considering in our generation, so many of us were bottle fed babies. Just like you and your DH, my DH and I were both bottle babies, and we are both healthy and intelligent. My husband is actually known for his intelligence; he is incredibly smart! I think about him often when that so-called rule of thumb is thrown out there about breastfed babies being so much more intelligent. Perhaps he would've been the next Einstein if he had been a boob boy, but I doubt it. I was so jealous in high school as he swept the awards banquet each year, lol. We joked that he might as well have brought in a dump truck and thrown ALL two million of his awards into the back to haul them home. So, yes, your baby will be just as smart as anyone else -- probably smarter due to the extreme love and attention you give your children. No worries there!

    You did your part, sweetie. I understand the emotions you are going through; they're normal. My best friend just bawled at her daughter's one week appt today for similar reasons! It's all par for the course when you're dealing with PP hormones. You are doing so well, and I love your pro list. Awesome that you can bring DH in on the action.... good for him to help you so much!!!! Get that well deserved sleep, girl. You've earned it!!!!
  6. Aww, thank you girls so much!!! All of your kind words truly made me feel better.

    The best news of all is that Jett is now officially ABOVE his birth weight!!! He gained 11 oz since Monday!!! (from 6.75 to 7.2) The dr was laughing and said "is that even possible?" LOL! When we got home from the appt he made a huge poop so I'm sure he lost a couple oz there. haha!

    Anyway, I love my pediatrician. He sat and talked to me for about a half hour about Jett and Jax. I told him about some issues we've been having with older J and he gave me GREAT advice and even offered to let me bring Jax in to talk to him.

    I am really happy with the way things are working out right now....I think it is for the best for a myriad of reasons.

    Thanks again girls!!!
  7. Oh, sorry C! There are pros and cons to both breast and bottle feeding, and you gave him colosturm--which is the most important thing to jump start a healthy immune system. Most pedis don't care either way if you use formula as long as the baby gets the first of the breast milk.
    Poor Jett! You done all you could, like you said sometimes it just doesn't work out. You can't fix what you don't know is broken, you had no way of knowing! I'm just glad that you feel better and are enjoying your happy boy! I'm also glad that Jason gets to feed him, that's an important tool for bonding.
    WTG Jett on the weight gain, he'll be a butterball before you know it ....I love little fat rolls on babies!
  8. everyone has said such supportive and true things - I can't say much more, but just wanted to offer my support. I have been through that type of experience with both of my girls, and once I had put everything into perspective and made a decision about bottle feeding, everything fell into place. Both of my girls are thriving and perfect (if I do say so myself!!!), so obviously formula is a good healthy choice for babies. There are a lot of emotions and social pressures that go on with feeding choices. Like others have said, you have to do what is best for your baby and you, and no one else... and that's it.

    I am glad that Jett is now thriving!!!
  9. 11oz in 3 days! That's crazy... go Jett!!! I'm so glad to hear that things are going well now . Can you send a clone of your pedi here? I need him. G's pedi office made some crazy changes before his 18 month check, so I've postponed it "until further notice". Our regular pedi moved out of state, and I didn't really love any of the others. Now they've got 3 new guys that nobody seems to like, and you're stuck with whomever is available. I've got to find somewhere new by his 2nd b-day.
  10. I'm sorry you had to quit bf. I am familiar with the disappointment you had.

    With my daughter I managed to bf for 2-3 weeks. She was constantly attached, fussy, and not gaining. I ate right, did everything they recommended(being lactation specialist and doc) and then some. At the end, they had me pump as much as I could which was 2 oz. between both breasts and had me set it in the fridge for 24 hours. Despite all the eating I was doing there was almost no fat at the top of my milk. So we went to formula. I had one day where I was 'full' and that was it. No engorging, no pain, nothing.

    With my son, he ate and ate and had trouble latching. At his 2 week appt, he was under his birth weight. When I switched to formula my breasts didn't even notice. There was no change.

    I cried and cried and cried. How could I make babies but not nourish them? Did that make me less of a woman? It certainly felt that way.

    I made peace with it pretty quickly by focusing on how much happier they both were when bottle fed. Now, my oldest is above grade level in math and reading and my little man is hitting 'skill' marks for a 3 year old. Formula in no way damaged them.

    I'm glad you have let go of any guilt or upset and can focus on how much happier it has made your family. Now your oldest can sit by you and 'feed' the baby by holding the bottle. My oldest loved to help like that.
  11. Wow, go Jett! And go, Mommy!
  12. I love your outlook on it all and its wonderful news that he is happier and gained so much weight already!
  13. YAY! I'm so glad to hear that things are going better. I understand exactly the frustration you were feeling. That sounds a lot like some of the things I went through with Noah. As soon as I started formula, we were both different people . Sometimes it works and sometimes it doesn't. You tried (HARD) and that's all you can do. Bfing isn't worth it when baby isn't healthy! And it is really nice to be able to let someone else do it. That is one of the things that I missed when nursing Cameron.


  14. Congrats on Jett, first and foremost (since I have been MIA for so long!)

    My SIL went through what you did... except that she was too stubborn to give up and instead swapped pedis. Unfortuantly she had several mommy friends at her church that were nursing and they sdid not give her very good advice. At 5 weeks old my neice, born a little over 9 pounds, was barely 7 pounds. 3 docs diagnosed her as failure to thrive and told my SIL, since she had laready been told abotu the issue, that the baby would need to be hospitalized if things got any worse, and if that happened the dept of social services would be brought in. She finally gave in. 9 months later that baby is a porker!! LOL

    Bottom line, breast aint always best!

    Me, I had enough milk for all of Africa.... causing my boobs to frighten my son and my milk to, even 20 minutes into letdown, shoot across the room. Two sips and he was drowning. A week in, I threw in the towel. I could pump 6 ounces from each side in 10 minutes. It took 30-45 minutes to convince himto latch, and within an hour of nursing he'd want to eat again. I had all the guilt you had for stopping. But... that first bottle I fed him (it was of stored milk, but still).... he was so calm and peaceful... I realized he was my baby and not some hungry little monster (LOL, kidding of course)

    You have to do what is best for you!

    And you are so right about all of those pros C!
  15. Thanks!! I go in to the pedi again next Wed and am anxious to see what he's gained. He is starting to somewhat fill out the 0-3 clothes now finally. They were all SWIMMING on him before. He's happy and healthy and that's what matters. I still get some twinges of disappointment (not really guilt), but generally I'm totally fine with our situation. It definitely is easier on my body and mental state.
  16. The best mommy is a happy and healthy mommy!!!
  17. I have had the opposite situation with my girls. I could not, despite valiant efforts, breastfeed Helen and at 6 weeks switched entirely to formula. Maria gave me very few problems, and she's fully breastfed now. So I also have been on both sides of the fence and while I think bf is easier in the end... formula feeding sure has it's perks (as you described). What I wouldn't give for longer between feedings or someone else to feed her right now. I'm dealing with a lot of resentment toward my sleeping husband in the middle of the night. Ha, ha! And I'm convinced that in the early months, it is much easier to watch an older child while bottle feeding an infant than breastfeeding (but maybe that's just "the grass is always greener" attitude coming out in me). It's not like you didn't give careful thought to the decision, so there is definitely nothing to be guilty about. I'm sorry that you are sometimes dealing with disappointment, but sometimes I deal with jealousy over the formula feeding moms so it wouldn't be perfect either way. Just embrace the good points of formula feeding and say "oh well" to the downsides. In a year, this will all be a moot point.
(17) comments | Add your comments